I got the wideband working properly tonight. It turns out that I was supposed to have a capacitor wired in to the analog wire and sent to ground to keep the "noise" at bay. I was using the wrong wire to go to the MS unit as well. The connector on the PLX wideband has wideband, narrowband, ground, and 3.3v. The 3.3v goes to the afr gauge (which is killer because I hated getting rid of my gauge), the wideband went to pin #23 on the MS along with the capacitor that came with my PLX (luckily I kept it in a safe place that I could actually find), and the ground went to pin #19 along with a ground coming from the capacitor.
So in short, I recommend checking the schematics for your particular wideband instead of relying on what you think you know or even the megamanual.
So in short, I recommend checking the schematics for your particular wideband instead of relying on what you think you know or even the megamanual.